Best Muffin Pans 2021

Last Updated on by Micheal Nathan

THE LIST OF THE BEST MUFFIN PANS 2021

NAMES FEATURES WHERE TO BUY
AmazonBasics Nonstick Carbon Steel Muffin Pan

B073P4RPFP

The set contains two pans; each pan with 24 cups.

It features a carbon-steel construction.

It is oven safe.

GET IT ON AMAZON
OXO Good Grips Non-Stick Pro Muffin

B015CQZR6I

Two-ply non-stick coating.

Scratch and stain-resistant.

Corrosion-resistant.

The heavy gauge manufacture makes it very durable.

GET IT ON AMAZON
Nordic Ware Natural Aluminum Commercial Muffin Pan

B000BZ9RKI

Never rust system

Superior heat conductivity

Easy to clean

Warping prevention system

GET IT ON AMAZON
Baker’s Secret Basics Nonstick 12-Cup Muffin Pan

B00091PMUS

Rust protection

Optimal browning system

Broiler-safe system

2-ply steel fortified with ETP

GET IT ON AMAZON
Farberware 46329 purECOok Muffin Pans

B01E5J81AC

Warp-resistant construction

Rolled rims

Wide handles

PFOA-free

GET IT ON AMAZON
Rachael Ray 54075 Muffin Pans

B07TJBH88C

Extra-wide handles

Orange silicone grips

Warp resistant system

Great food release

GET IT ON AMAZON
Wilton Recipe Right Muffin Pan, 12-Cup Non-Stick Muffin Pan

B003W0UMPI

Fast and even heating.

Dishwasher safe.

Plastic cover included in the box.

5-year limited warranty.

GET IT ON AMAZON
Silicone Muffin Pan Cupcake Set – Mini 24

B0746CWTXF

100% silicone mold

The surface is nonstick and flexible

Great for making muffin, tart, bread, mousse, jelly

High-quality products

GET IT ON AMAZON
Calphalon 12-cup Nonstick Muffin Pan

B0009EYIRS

Heavy steel core will not warp

The interior of each piece has interlocking layers

Designed to bring out the long term release

Lifetime warranty

Food safety for your family

GET IT ON AMAZON
USA Pan Crown Quick Release Coating Muffin Pan

B001TO3CNI

Made from commercial grade and heavy gauge aluminized steel

There Americoat helps promote quick removal

Wash with mild soap hot water, and a gentle scrub sponge or brush

Silicone coatings do not contain PFOA, PTFE, and BPA

GET IT ON AMAZON

Muffin lovers are always keen about the kind of pan they use for their muffins. The muffin pans give the muffin its shape.

This guide focuses on showing the best muffin pans out there. You should endeavor to go through this guide for all the points you need to know about getting the muffin pan.

What Is Muffin Pan?

A muffin pan is one kind of bakeware or baking tray that consists of multiple round wells or connecting cups. The primary function of this tray-like kitchen utensil is for oven use.

It is similar to a cupcake pan but the depressions in the tray are larger and help to hold muffins. Each depression is about 1.5 inches deep and 4 inches in diameter.

Different Types Of Muffin Pans

As with nearly every type of cookware, the classification of muffin pans is based on the type of material used in their construction. Therefore, the following are the major types-

  • Aluminum Muffin Pans

Nearly half of the muffin pans that you will find in the market feature an aluminum construction. It is a famous choice for most people because of its good conductivity. Also, even heat distribution means that you will get uniformly baked goods that are attractive and tasty.

Aluminum pans are lightweight and convenient. However, the primary downside of these types of pans lies in strength. They could warp when subjected to rapid temperature changes. Multi-layered options will perform better.

  • Stainless Steel

Another popular type of muffin pan is stainless steel. The material boasts of unbeatable strength. They are resistant to corrosion and warping. Thus, a stainless steel muffin pan will be your kitchen companion for several years. Cleaning stainless steel is perfectly easy, so you don’t need to fret.

The only demerit of this type of pans is that they are poorer conductors of heat as compared to their aluminum counterparts. That means that they take slightly longer to heat and the entire baking process may be slower.

  • Carbon Steel

These muffin pans feature a carbon and steel alloy construction. So, it blends the strength of steel and the lightweight of carbon in one piece of cookware. They stand out as perfectly easy to season, clean, and will remain nonstick with proper care and maintenance.

  • Steel

This will probably surprise you. However, you will find a few options in the market that feature regular steel construction. The category consists of the sturdiest and most durable option. They feature a nonstick coating that guards them against corrosion.

  • Nonstick Muffin Pans

The most essential property of muffin pans is the nonstick ability. Nonstick pans feature construction from any durable material and a nonstick coating. It prevents muffin batter accumulation on pan surfaces hence easy to remove.

  • Silicone Muffin Pans

The most common reason why bakers prefer silicone muffin pans is their nonstick capabilities. The best silicone muffin pans come flexible. Such a feature implies that you can easily pop out muffins from the flexible tray.

A good formulation of silicone is equally a wonderful heat conductor. However, even the distribution of heat can be a problem. Besides, silicone is soft and flexible hence may often produce malformed muffins. You can prevent that by primarily using silicone trays to line up a heavy-duty muffin pan.

MUFFIN PANS BUYER’S GUIDE

Ergonomics

Being comfortable and safe to use is key. Features like a non-slip handle should be favored. This will ensure you do not hurt yourself or spill your pastry when putting them inside your oven or pulling them out.

Also, one that has a design that provides increased airflow between muffins will generally give you better results. Easy cleaning after use should also be looked at closely.

Construction

Best muffin pans are manufactured from different materials. There are a few things to consider in this regard.

Firstly, even heat distribution. This guarantees you even cooking and prevents hot spots that easily ruin your food. Also, go for a material that offers you the most durability. It should be non-stick or offer you a durable non-stick surface.

A pan that is rust and corrosion-resistant heats quickly, and does not warp is generally a better idea. So, you can be sure it can withstand the elements. Also, only favor a pan whose non-stick coat does not flake or chip and is durable enough to remain non-stick over time.

A dishwasher compatible model, while optional, is a good pick if you need this feature.

Capacity

Depending on your user needs, you should check the dimensions or your muffin pan, and the dimensions of each muffin hole. This is important, as several manufacturers offer you the same capacity in their 6 cups, 12 cups, and 24 cup variants.

While the most common is smaller cup sizes and more muffins. You could, however, dig a little to find what best suits your needs.

Unique Features

Here comes color, shape, hue, etc. This is not irrelevant so pick a pan that you will be happy to see and use every day. Also, a few models allow for hang-type storage. You should go for a pan that does if you need this feature.

BEST MUFFIN PANS

AmazonBasics Nonstick Carbon Steel Muffin Pan

B073P4RPFP

You can’t go wrong with the AmazonBasics Nonstick Carbon Steel Muffin Pan. It is a pretty, moderately priced bakeware that contains two trays in the set. Each tray contains up to 12 cups which means you have a total of 24 cups. Isn’t that enough for the entire family?

This safest muffin pan features a carbon steel construction. You will agree with us that such a non-toxic and heavy-weight composition will last for a long time. It resists warping and heats evenly to provide uniform baking and rising. Even more, the set features a nonstick coating to guarantee the easy removal of your muffins.

PROS CONS
  • The nonstick coating enables easy removal of your foods.
  • The nonstick lining isn’t durable but you can use silicone liners.
  • The heavy-weight construction is rust-proof and durable.
  • It is not dishwasher safe.
  • It is versatile and goes beyond baking muffins.
  • You can easily hand wash them.

OXO Good Grips Non-Stick Pro Muffin

B015CQZR6I

This 12-cup muffin pan from OXO Good Grips helps you create a flawlessly beautiful and professionally made muffin with its nonstick properties. As this pan is made of aluminum, it helps in the even distribution of heat in your muffin batter and has an easy release. Furthermore, it’s built of the best quality materials for it to be useful in the years to come.

This aluminum-based steel contains ceramic and PFOA-free coating which makes it safe to use, durable, and easy to remove. While steel is prone to scratches, staining, and corrosion, this product is resistant to the said permanent damages.

PROS CONS
  • Sturdy and light-colored
  • Pans are prone to warps upon exposure to intense heat or after several uses
  • Features even heat distribution that fully cooks the muffin inside and out
  • Contains nonstick properties for easy baking and less to zero holes on the product

Nordic Ware Natural Aluminum Commercial Muffin Pan

B000BZ9RKI

Made of 12 wells for easy batch baking, this product from Nordic ware is purely made of aluminum. Aluminum helps in equal distribution of the heat, resulting in evenly baked muffins.

Additionally, the pan also contains an encapsulated steel rim for the prevention of warping, making it usable for a long period of time. Its overall design is easy to clean; therefore, areas with fragments from the baked product can easily be cleaned through hand washing.

PROS CONS
  • Easy cleanup
  • Only hand-washed
  • Prevents warping
  • Lifetime durability
  • Standard 12 muffin pan
  • Natural aluminum commercial bakeware

Baker’s Secret Basics Nonstick 12-Cup Muffin Pan

B00091PMUS

If you are looking for the best quality-price ratio, the Baker’s Secret Non-Stick muffin pan is the original non-stick metal bakeware for obtaining perfect cupcakes. Its performance is great from the start to the finish line. The Baker’s Secret is metal bakeware and provides even baking results. Easy to release baked goods, the pan is also very easy to clean up.

PROS CONS
  • Enhanced with durability and rust protection
  • Use only non-metal utensils
  • Delivers even cooking results
  • Easy release baked goods
  • Nonstick coating
  • Dishwasher safe

Farberware 46329 purECOok Muffin Pans

B01E5J81AC

If you are looking for a ceramic muffin pan for some time, then consider this Farberware Muffin Pan review. Obtain great baked muffins and always experiment baking single-serving treats of all kinds.

Perfect for oven cooking, you can use the Farberware Muffin Pan for baking from simple to special desserts. The nonstick surface helps home baking become great.

PROS CONS
  • Easy food release and cleanup
  • You need to hand wash it
  • Better baking browning
  • Very durable in time
  • Non-stick surface

Rachael Ray 54075 Muffin Pans

B07TJBH88C

One of the easiest to use muffin pans, the Rachael Ray bakeware is a kitchen tool ready to help you prepare meals from the very start to finish. If you are looking to bake tasty cupcakes, this muffin pan is colorful and adds beautiful hues and rich flavor to any of your dishes.

PROS CONS
  • Oven safe to 500 degrees Fahrenheit
  • Ask for a warranty from the seller
  • Warp resistant heavy gauge steel
  • Excellent food release
  • Easy cleanup
  • Nonstick pan

Wilton Recipe Right Muffin Pan, 12-Cup Non-Stick Muffin Pan

B003W0UMPI

The Wilton Recipe Right muffin pan can hold up to 12 muffins at once. Made of stainless steel, it is very durable. It is reinforced with a durable non-stick coating that releases your foods easily. This feature also makes it quite easy to clean.

The handles are widened and as such, are comfortable to use, even with those mittens on. The handles also have hanging holes for easier drying or storage. Fast and even heating, as well as its dishwasher compatibility, you get it all with this product.

This best muffin pan is included with a 5-year limited warranty and comes with a plastic cover that is helpful when you need to cover your food.

PROS CONS
  • Wide handles for easy and safe use.
  • Not heavy-duty, so it bends – but can be straightened by hand.
  • Hanging holes for drying or storage.
  • Non-stick coated.
  • Durable product.

Silicone Muffin Pan Cupcake Set – Mini 24

B0746CWTXF

The CAKE TIME Muffin Pan will is the next product to increase the abundance in this review list. From my perspective, it has many reviews about the best silicone material design available today. It totally deserves that title for its 100% guarantee of food-grade premium silicone.

Non-stick surface and safety help you have quality cakes. You only use your fingers to press the bottom of the pan to make the cake slide out easily and then release your hand to return to the original mold shape. Usage is very flexible and maximum efficient.

Moreover, it not only works well with an oven or microwave but also with a refrigerator and freezer. From there, you can use it flexibly in how to prepare with different recipes for cakes or making pudding or jelly. A surprise is the addition of a 12-cup standard-size tray and 12pcs cupcake liners.

PROS CONS
  • Enjoy healthier food with family and friends
  • The item may be flimsy and melt in the oven
  • You can grill more dishes at once
  • Very difficult to clean grease off of
  • Easy to remove food and clean
  • Save time, save money

Calphalon 12-cup Nonstick Muffin Pan

B0009EYIRS

The Calphalon always creates the best baking ware products to assist you in your cooking life. It is also used for cupcakes, muffins, cornbreads, etc.

The structure is a dense and durable steel core, so it is safe and lasts for a long time. Besides, it also resists warping and helps spread heat evenly throughout the pan to limit heat gathering only in some places. Thus, the outer crust is even brown, and the inside is soft and fragrant.

With the perfect and nonstick design, you can get a batch of cakes with 12 cups in one baking. I strongly support the view that this muffin pan model is two times better than Calphalon Classic Bakeware. Once you’re done, please put it in the dishwasher to clean.

PROS CONS
  • Effortlessly bake all your favorite cakes and biscuits
  • Difficult to remove trapped food
  • Create a beautiful brown cake
  • Safe with a dishwasher
  • High-quality material

USA Pan Crown Quick Release Coating Muffin Pan

B001TO3CNI

USA Pan Bakeware Crown Muffin Pan has up to 12 wells, each of which is 2.75×1.63×1.53 inches, for oversized muffins. This pan is made from commercial steel and aluminized steel commercially manufactured in the US so that you can rest assured.

The unique corrugated iron surfaces are designed to enhance non-stick properties and strengthen pans to prevent warping. With durable, reliable design and high performance, it provides an ideal heating distribution and increases airflow to create the perfect muffin.

The USA Pan muffin pan has Americoat – a silicone-free coating of PTFE, PFOA, and BPA. It provides a non-stick surface and helps to quickly release all baking and cleaning products with minimum ease. You can add a small amount of mild soap dissolved with hot water.

PROS CONS
  • The muffins come out onto the counter after resting for a couple of minutes
  • There may be scratches on the surface
  • The weight is excellent for heating and baking the best muffins at home
  • Not safe with dishwasher
  • The pan is spotless after quickly removing cakes
  • No pan spray needed

CONCLUSION

Although making muffins is easy, you should use the right baking pan to ensure that you will successfully achieve an evenly baked, well-shaped muffin. Nonstick material is highly recommended, not only for muffins pans but also for cake pans and other baking pans as well for easy removal of the finished baked masterpieces.